Current:Home > FinanceCourt Orders New Climate Impact Analysis for 4 Gigantic Coal Leases -Ascend Finance Compass
Court Orders New Climate Impact Analysis for 4 Gigantic Coal Leases
View
Date:2025-04-17 05:28:47
A federal appeals court in Denver told the Bureau of Land Management on Friday that its analysis of the climate impacts of four gigantic coal leases was economically “irrational” and needs to be done over.
When reviewing the environmental impacts of fossil fuel projects under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), the judges said, the agency can’t assume the harmful effects away by claiming that dirty fuels left untouched in one location would automatically bubble up, greenhouse gas emissions and all, somewhere else.
That was the basic logic employed by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) in 2010 when it approved the new leases in the Powder River Basin that stretches across Wyoming and Montana, expanding projects that hold some 2 billion tons of coal, big enough to supply at least a fifth of the nation’s needs.
The leases were at Arch Coal’s Black Thunder mine and Peabody Energy’s North Antelope-Rochelle mine, among the biggest operations of two of the world’s biggest coal companies. If these would have no climate impact, as the BLM argued, then presumably no one could ever be told to leave coal in the ground to protect the climate.
But that much coal, when it is burned, adds billions of tons of carbon dioxide to an already overburdened atmosphere, worsening global warming’s harm. Increasingly, environmentalists have been pressing the federal leasing agency to consider those cumulative impacts, and increasingly judges have been ruling that the 1970 NEPA statute, the foundation of modern environmental law, requires it.
The appeals court ruling is significant, as it overturned a lower court that had ruled in favor of the agency and the coal mining interests. It comes as the Trump administration is moving to reverse actions taken at the end of the Obama administration to review the coal leasing program on climate and economic grounds.
“This is a major win for climate progress, for our public lands, and for our clean energy future,” said Jeremy Nichols of WildEarth Guardians, which filed the appeal along with the Sierra Club. “It also stands as a major reality check to President Trump and his attempts to use public lands and coal to prop up the dying coal industry at the expense of our climate.”
But the victory for the green plaintiffs may prove limited. The court did not throw out the lower court’s ruling, a remedy that would have brought mining operations to a halt. Nor, in sending the case back for further review, did it instruct the lower court how to proceed, beyond telling it not “to rely on an economic assumption, which contradicted basic economic principles.”
It was arbitrary and capricious, the appeals court said, for BLM to pretend that there was no “real world difference” between granting and denying coal leases, on the theory that the coal would simply be produced at a different mine.
The appeals court favorably quoted WildEarth’s argument that this was “at best a gross oversimplification.” The group argued that Powder River coal, which the government lets the companies have at rock-bottom prices, is extraordinarily cheap and abundant. If this supply were cut off, prices would rise, leading power plants to switch to other, cheaper fuels. The result would be lower emissions of carbon dioxide.
For the BLM to argue that coal markets, like a waterbed, would rise here if pushed down there, was “a long logical leap,” the court ruled.
veryGood! (2571)
Related
- Alex Murdaugh’s murder appeal cites biased clerk and prejudicial evidence
- Harold N. Weinberg
- The Michigan supreme court set to decide whether voters see abortion on the ballot
- CDC investigates an E. coli outbreak in 4 states after some Wendy's customers fell ill
- Krispy Kreme offers a free dozen Grinch green doughnuts: When to get the deal
- Natural Gas Flaring: Critics and Industry Square Off Over Emissions
- See the Best Dressed Stars Ever at the Kentucky Derby
- Flash Deal: Save 67% On Top-Rated Peter Thomas Roth Anti-Aging Skincare
- The city of Chicago is ordered to pay nearly $80M for a police chase that killed a 10
- What’s Worrying the Plastics Industry? Your Reaction to All That Waste, for One
Ranking
- The FTC says 'gamified' online job scams by WhatsApp and text on the rise. What to know.
- Star Wars Day 2023: Shop Merch and Deals From Stoney Clover Lane, Fanatics, Amazon, and More
- Clifton Garvin
- Shaquil Barrett’s Wife Jordanna Pens Heartbreaking Message After Daughter’s Drowning Death
- Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
- CDC investigates an E. coli outbreak in 4 states after some Wendy's customers fell ill
- Edward E. David
- How North West Saved Mom Kim Kardashian's Met Gala 2023 Dress
Recommendation
Kylie Jenner Shows Off Sweet Notes From Nieces Dream Kardashian & Chicago West
Highlighting the Allure of Synfuels, Exxon Played Down the Climate Risks
Why you should stop complimenting people for being 'resilient'
Kendall Jenner Only Used Drugstore Makeup for Her Glamorous Met Gala 2023 Look
Grammy nominee Teddy Swims on love, growth and embracing change
Military jets scrambled due to unresponsive small plane over Washington that then crashed in Virginia
Today’s Climate: May 31, 2010
Spoiler Alert: A Paul Ryan-Led House Unlikely to Shift on Climate Issues